Menu
- STARTERS
- Sandwiches + Tacos
- Greens + Bowls + Soups
- Chicken + Steak + Pasta
- Seafood
- Sushi
- Sidewinders
- Beverages
- Cocktail Bar
-
Bellie Banger Shrimp or Grouper
Fried and tossed in a mildly spicy honey mustard sauce.
Shrimp $12
Grouper $14
-
Buffalo Shrimp
Fried shrimp tossed in Buffalo wing sauce. Served with bleu cheese and celery.
$12
-
Garlic Mussels
A big bowl of black mussels in garlic white wine. Served with bread for dipping.
$16
Garlic Middleneck Clams $23
Garlic Peel + Eat Shrimp $20
-
Calamari
A mound of tender calamari, hand breaded and lightly fried. Served with marinara.
$13
-
Peel + Eat Gulf Shrimp
Caught on our own boat! Served hot, peel + eat style.
1 lb $25
1/2 lb $15
-
Teeha Marie Fish Spread
Smoked fresh, in-house. Served with fresh veggies and crackers.
$13
-
NEW Sesame Ginger Ahi Tuna
Served rare with a chilled Asia slaw + ginger glaze.
$16
-
Ceviche Stack
Layers of homemade guacamole, seafood ceviche + mango salsa. Served with corn chips.
$16
-
Traditional Ceviche
Fresh fish, shrimp and scallops, marinated with tomato, onion, herbs and spices. Served with crispy tortilla chips.
$14
-
Crab Rangoons
Sweet snow crab meat, creamy blend of cheeses in a crispy wonton.
$15
-
Crab Cake
One jumbo crab cake loaded with deliciously sweet crabmeat. Served atop cilantro lime and remoulade.
$16
-
Chicken Wings
Fried and tossed in mildly spicy sweet buffalo sauce. Served with bleu cheese and celery.
$16
-
Fried Brussels Sprouts
Crispy sprouts tossed in a creamy aioli. Finished with grated parmesan and lemon.
$9
-
Feta Artichoke Dip
Served warm with corn tortilla chips.
$13
-
Steamed Edamame
Choice of Juicy Style | Chili | Lime | Sea Salt
$8
Served with fries.
-
Redman Grouper Sandwich
Served grilled, blackened or fried on a toasted bun with lettuce, tomato, and onion. Served with fries.
MKT $29
-
NEW Major's Crispy Grouper
Panko crusted local grouper, lettuce, tomato, pickled red onion, tangy pickles and tartar.
$28
-
Market Mahi
Fried Mahi, bibb lettuce, pickled red onion, avocado, tomato and cilantro lime sauce.
$16
-
Hard Times Po' Boy
Fried shrimp, lettuce, tomato, dill sauce and scallions on a hoagie roll.
$14
-
Anclote Cluck
Fried chicken, buffalo sauce, bibb lettuce, bleu cheese, bacon and pickled red onions.
$14
-
Double Eagle Chicken Sandwich
Grilled, blackened or fried with cheddar and bacon.
$13
-
Big Beautiful Burger
Hand made and topped with cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato and onion.
$14
-
Uncle Stevie
Grilled onions, provolone cheese, toasted baguette.
$18
-
90 Miles to Cuban
Mojo pork, salami, swiss cheese, pickles and MM sauce.
$14
tacos
Two flour tortillas filled with shredded cabbage, pico de gallo, cheddar cheese and chipotle ranch. Served with black beans and rice. $15 Ditch the tortillas for bibb lettuce wraps. $1-
Fried Shrimp
$15
-
Blackened Catch
$15
-
Blackened Grouper
$18
-
Blackened Chicken
$15
Available dressings:
House (Key Lime Vinaigrette), Blue Cheese, Greek Vinaigrette, Honey Lemon Poppyseed, Honey Mustard, Caesar + Ranch
-
Bellie's Signature Salad
Mixed greens, candied pecans, golden raisins, green apple, red onion, tomato, and goat cheese crumbles. Served with honey lemon poppyseed dressing.
$11
-
Greek Salad
Kalamata olives, cukes, bell pepper, onion, wedge tomato, chickpeas, beets and feta cheese. Topped with a scoop of potato salad.
$13
-
Caesar Salad
Romaine, homemade croutons, parmesan cheese and homemade dressing.
$8
-
Side Caesar Salad
$5
-
Side Signature
$5
-
Side Garden
$5
Additions:
Chicken $5
Shrimp $11
Steak $12
Avocado $1
-
Rusty's Cobb Salad
Fried Gulf shrimp, bacon, egg, tomato, onion, cheddar cheese and a pinch of fried onion straws.
$16
-
NEW Mini Greek + Peel & Eat
Mini Greek salad and 6hote peel + eat steamed shrimp.
$16
-
Kitchen Sink + Greens
Crispy chicken, puffed rice, mixed greens, haloumi cheese, cucumber, tomatoes, red onion, watermelon radish, avocado, warm naan, spicy mayo and key lime vinaigrette.
$17
-
1946 Steak Salad
Mixed greens. tomatoes, crispy soft cooked egg, medium rare sirloin, croutons, and shaved parmesan.
$18
-
Blackened Salmon Spinach Salad
Spinach, chopped egg, bacon, onion, tomato, sunflower seeds, dried cranberries, key lime vinaigrette, and topped with blackened salmon.
$23
-
Little Poke
Raw, marinated ahi tuna, fresh veggies, sesame seeds, masago, avocado, and spicy mayo.
$16
-
The Big Ka-Tuna Rice Bowl
Raw, marinated ahi tuna, jasmine rice, avocado, pineapple, seaweed salad, fresh veggies, sesame seeds, masago and poke mayo.
$24
Soups
-
Crab Bisque
Rich, creamy and delicious.
$8
-
Seafood Gumbo
Mussels, clams and shrimp with chicken and sausage in a rich roux.
$8
-
Maria's Jumbo Gumbo
A big helping of traditional gumbo served over jasmine rice.
$12
-
16oz Blackboard Steak
The best BIG ribeye in town! Seasoned and grilled perfectly. Served with two sided and fresh bread.
$42
-
Chicken Dakota
A perfectly pan seared breast of chicken with sauteed artichokes and fire roasted tomatoes in a light lemon cream sauce. Served over rice and finished with feta cheese and basil.
$19
-
Fat Cat Chicken Cajun Alfredo
Cajun alfredo topped with blackened chicken.
$18
-
NEW Carly Sue Redux
Blackened shrimp skewers over four cheese grits, topped with a cajun cream sauce, diced tomatoes, bacon, and scallions.
$19
-
Seafood Mac & Cheese
Creamy Gruyere and sharp cheddar bechamel over rigatoni with layers of Gulf shrimp and bay scallops. Served with garlicky toast points.
$33
-
Little Joe
A trio of bay scallops, Gulf shrimp and mussels in garlic white wine sauce over linguini.
$24
Make it Alfredo $26
-
NEW Pesto Pasta
A cozy bowl of pesto, fire roasted tomatoes and rigatoni. Served with garlicky toast.
$15
Signature Seafood Favorites
-
NEW Rusty's Cajun Gulf Grouper
Locally caught Gulf grouper atop fingerling potatoes and green beans with shiitake mushrooms. Finished with Cajun lump crab cream sauce.
$36
-
Madame Butterly
Fresh Gulf shrimp, served grilled or blackened with two sides.
$24
-
Rusty's Signature Salmon
Faroe Island salmon, fingerling potatoes, green beans with shiitake mushrooms and finished with warm lemon dill sauce.
$26
-
E. Sea Rider
Grilled skewers of shrimp and sea scallops paired with a fillet of fish. Served over yellow rice.
Mahi $34
Grouper $42
Salmon $36
-
NEW Mahi Piccata
Seared mahi atop jasmine rice and seasonal veggies in a creamy, lemon caper sauce and topped with diced tomatoes.
$24
-
Snapper Due West
Panko encrusted American Red Snapper, fingerling potatoes, asparagus and blistered tomatoes. Finished with a Key Lime cream sauce, fresh avocado and two large Gulf shrimp.
$39
-
86 Proof
Faroe Island salmon and bacon wrapped domestic scallops over jasmine rice, green beans + shiitake mushrooms and finished with a sweet bourbon glaze.
$34
-
Jack's Shrimp Trio
Straight off the shrimp boat! Bellie Banger shrimp, 6 peel + eat shrimp and shrimp scampi.
$34
Steamed Seafood
-
Madame Butterly
Fresh Gulf shrimp, served grilled or blackened with two sides.
$24
choice of:
traditional jack juice, a signature blend of olive oil, lemon + spices
or
eleni's juicy boil, a cajun style mix of onions, garlic, spices + heat (shaken tableside)
-
cedar key middleneck clams
2.5 dz $19
1 dz $9
-
peel + eat shrimp
caught on our own boat! served hot, peel + eat style.
1 lb $25
1/2 lb $15
-
snow crab clusters
weighed to order, a full pound and a half of the best snow crab you'll find!
$36
-
rusty's pot belly bucket
snow crab, gulf shrimp, mussels, clams, smoked sausage, potatoes, citrus + a hard boiled egg for good luck!
$42
A note about snow crab
We source the very best snow crab we can find. Due to the wild caught, unfarmed nature of snow crab, variations in meat to shell ratio will occur. Please know we weigh to order and encourage you to order with this in mind.
Fried Seafood
served with fried and slaw.
substitute side for $1 each.
-
Madame Butterfly FRIED
Our original fried shrimp. Lightly breaded and fried.
$22
-
galilee
Shrimp, bay scallops, clam strips, and fresh catch bites.
$29
-
early out
Mullet fillets fresh from Tarpon Springs.
$15
-
NEW Blue Star
Panko breaded baby bay scallops.
$18
-
NEW Julie Ann Boat Run Shrimp
A hearty plate of panko breaded Gulf pink shrimp. Boat Run = shrimp of all size!
$20
-
New England Wholebelly Clams
mkt $34
-
Fresh Catch Bites
$16
grouper bites $27
-
Clam Strips
$16
-
Calamari
$17
-
fish & chips
Domestic cod, double battered and fried.
$18
Available:
Thursday - Sunday
4pm - CLOSE
* our krab is made from Alaskan pollock
-
Miguel Roll
Real snow crab, cream cheese, avocado and cucumber. Topped with spicy salmon, masago and sesame chili oil.
$16
-
Volcano Roll
Ahi tuna, asparagus, cream cheese and avocado. Topped with baked spicy conch and real snow crab mix.
$16
-
Crunchy Spicy Tuna Roll
Spicy tuna and avocado. Topped with crunchy tempura.
$11
-
Fire Roll
Spicy tuna, cucumber and avocado. Topped with raw scallop and krab* mix.
$15
-
Tuna Tower
Spicy tuna, ahi tuna, rice, eel sauce, tempura shrimp, ponzu sauce and sesame oil. Topped with green onion and sesame seeds.
$15
-
Pauszu Roll
Krab meat, salmon, cucumber, avocado and cream cheese. Topped with eel sauce, coconut flakes, macadamia nuts and scallions.
$16
-
Sponger Roll
Tempura shrimp, cucumber and avocado. Topped with sweet and spicy tuna.
$14
-
Moo Moo Roll
Avocado, asparagus, cilantro, green onion and bleu cheese crumbles. Topped with medium rare steak, jalapeno and chimichurri sauce.
$14
-
Hawaiian Roll
Coconut shrimp, cream cheese, apsaragus and cucumber. Topped with mango, avocado, roasted macadamia nuts and coconut flakes.
$14
-
California Roll
Real snow crab meat, cucumber and avocado.
$12
-
Lotus Flower
Blackened tuna, cream cheese, jalapeno and green onion. Topped with avocado, spicy shrimp mix, eel sauce, spicy mayo and microgreens.
$14
-
Dragonfly Roll
Tuna, salmon, cream cheese and cucumber. Topped with avocado, mango sauce and Japanese seasoning.
$15
-
Long Gone Roll
Panko grouper, avocado, cream cheese and spicy mayo. Topped with tuna, masago, garlicky soy sauce drizzle and wonton strips.
$16
-
Birthday Roll
Crab meat, cucumber, avocado and spicy tuna. Topped with spicy scallops , crunchy tempura and spicy sauce.
$14
-
Fire the Cannons Roll
Cucumber, avocado, cream cheese, salmon, krab meat and spicy mayo. Topped with tuna, black roe and sweet spicy sauce.
$16
Sides
-
Bacon Brussel Gratin
$5
-
Baked Potato (after 4pm)
$5
-
Black Beans + Rice
$5
-
Cole Slaw
$5
-
Corn Casserole
$5
-
French Fries
$5
-
Green Beans + Shiitake Mushrooms
$5
-
Loaded Skillet Fries
$5
-
Potato Salad
$5
-
Yellow Rice
$5
Minnows
Served with French fries or applesauce. Kids fountain drink included. Under 12 only.-
Fried Shrimp
$7
-
Kraft Mac & Cheese
$7
-
Chicken Tenders
$7
-
Fried Fish
$7
Beverages
-
Fountain Sodas, Iced Tea, Coffee
$3.50
-
Juice + Milk
each $4
-
Saratoga Water
Sparkling or Still
each $7
-
Old Fashioned Shirley Temple + Cherry Coke
$5
Happy Hour
Daily 3 - 6pm $5 HOUSE Margarita + Sangria + Bloody Mary $1 OFF HOUSE Wine $1 OFF Traditional Draft BeerZero Proof
-
Pineapple Mock-arita
Fresh Lime, pineapple, soda + salted rim.
$7
-
Blue Lagoon
Lemonade, blue raspberry, Sprite + Gummie Fish.
$7
-
Blackberry Vanilla Fizz
Sweet tea, fresh lemonade + black puree.
$7
Authentic Tiki Drinks
Our signature rum blend consists of premium Jamaican + Martinique rums. Blending rums is an homage to flavor profiles found in authentic, mid-century tiki drinks. Enter the Tiki Grotto with caution as these pack a punch!-
Authentic Mai Tai*
An ode to Trader Vic’s! RB rum blend, housemade orgeat + fresh lime! *contains nuts
$16
-
FAT BOB
RB rum blend, pineapple juice, orange juice, honey ginger syrup + coconut cream.
$16
-
Goombay Smash
An island classic. RB rum blend, apricot brandy, orange juice, pineapple juice, grenadine + coconut cream.
$14
Signature Cocktails
-
Full Bellie Bloody Mary
spicy vodka, Gulf shrimp, bacon, veggies + a hushpuppy skewer.
$14
-
House Sangria
Housemade with seasonal fruit + cinnamon.
Glass $9
Pitcher $25
-
White Sangria
Housemade with seasonal fruit.
Glass $9
Pitcher $25
-
Tarpon Mule
Tito's Vodka, ginger beer, lime + candied ginger.
$12
-
Key Lime Pie Martini
RumChata, vanilla vodka, key lime + a graham cracker rim.
$14
-
Smoke Signals
Bulleit Rye Whiskey, orange, cherry + smoked cedar.
$14
-
Fired Apple Manhattan
Maker's Mark Bourbon, apple liqueur, vermouth, bitters + smoked cedar.
$14
-
Cucumber Basil Gimlet
Hendrick's Gin, St. Germain, fresh basil, cucumbers + ginger beer.
$12
-
3 Lime Skinny Margarita
Libelula Tequila, Tippler’s, agave, fresh lime juice.
$14
-
Pink Mango Margarita
Margaritaville Last Mango Tequila, Tippler’s + cranberry.
$12
-
Spicy Margarita
Tanteo Jalapeño Tequila, Tippler’s + lime.
$12
-
Prickly Pair Margarita
Libelula Tequila, prickly pear puree, fresh lime juice, fresh ruby red grapefruit, sparkling tonic + a salted rim.
$12
-
House Mojito
Flor de Caña Rum, mint + lime. available flavors: blackberry | strawberry | peach
$12
-
Coconut Mojito
RumHaven Coconut Rum, coconut cream, muddled mint, lime + graham cracker rim.
$12
Extras
-
original frose
A frozen delight of rosé, peach, strawberry + vodka.
$12
-
San Frose
The local favorite! Swirled layers of Frosé + signature house sangria.
$12
-
Pineapple Mock-arita
Fresh lime, pineapple soda + salted rim.
$7
-
Blue Lagoon
Lemonade, blue raspberry, Sprite + gummie fish.
$7
-
Blackberry Vanilla Fizz
Sweet tea, fresh lemonade + blackberry puree.
$7